Key takeaways

  • Gabriel Collins and Andrew S. Erickson warn that China could seek control of Taiwan’s semiconductor industry through coercion and a forced sale rather than an invasion.
  • In the authors’ hypothetical 2027 scenario, TSMC’s market capitalization falls from $700 billion to $300 billion during sustained PLA live-fire exercises around Taiwan.
  • The scenario’s buyout offer has China’s National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund and SMIC seeking a 51% controlling stake in TSMC, financed by China Investment Corporation.
  • Beijing’s pressure in the scenario works through inspection demands, insurer warnings and halted air cargo, shrinking Taiwan’s food and fuel stockpiles while unemployment rises.
  • Collins and Erickson judge that such a bloodless gambit could tempt Beijing with a favorable risk/reward balance.

Suggested Citation: Collins, Gabriel and Andrew S. Erickson. 2023. Silicon Hegemon: Could China Take Over Taiwan’s Semiconductor Industry without Invading? Report no. 09.27.23. Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy, Houston, Texas. https://doi.org/10.25613/D4ER-0D37.

Full Report PDF here

A Scenario of Concern

Imagine the following hypothetical contingency:

August 1, 2027, 0600 CST, Beijing: Having achieved Xi’s Centennial Military Building Goal, China’s armed forces now offer their Commander-in-Chief a full toolbox of military capabilities regarding Taiwan. Xi insists as never before on changing cross-Strait conditions on his own terms. During this relentless ramp-up over the past several years, progressive intensification of an all-domain pressure campaign heightened fears in Taiwan. Efforts to address them amid increasingly polarized politics have opened up unprecedented vulnerabilities in Taiwan’s economy to PRC ownership and influence.

Beginning May 1, 2024, the PLA began intensive but intermittent live fire “exercises” around Taiwan. Hundreds of munitions have been fired at flying, floating, and subsurface targets offshore from the key avenues of approach to the island. Beijing issued notices to mariners and airmen to avoid the entire periphery of Taiwan. As exercises commenced, Xi personally spoke with the heads of key vendors and customers of Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Ltd. (TSMC), United Microelectronics Corp. (UMC), and Powerchip Technology Corp. to assure them that shipments to and from those firms’ fabrication plants[10] as well as coal and gas shipments to power plants supporting the fabs are secure.

Beijing has demanded that aircraft seeking to land in Taiwan first land at the Xiamen Gaoqi International or Quanzhou Jinjiang international airports and that ships first call at PRC ports or anchor in an inspection zone off the coast of Fujian province for inspection. Other vessels and aircraft have been intercepted offshore by PRC “safety escorts” and ordered to exit the area.

Many shippers have avoided sailing into the area following warnings from their London-based insurers, and most air cargo services have halted operations for as long as PRC military activities continue in Taiwan’s vicinity. As food and fuel stockpiles dwindle and unemployment rises, Taiwan faces an internal political crisis, and voices supporting accommodation with Beijing are gaining strength. Meanwhile, the White House has so far refused to have U.S. military assets transit PRC exercise exclusion zones to uphold freedom of navigation.

This morning the heads of China’s National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund and Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation called TSMC’s chairman with a private offer: They have a line of credit from China Investment Corporation to purchase a 51% controlling stake in TSMC, whose market capitalization has fallen from $700 billion at the onset of China’s action to $300 billion now. If TSMC and Taipei accept the deal, Beijing has pledged upon its financial closing to defend all future air and sea traffic in and out of the island. Alternatively, it may continue unspecified “exercises” for weeks or months to come.

Such a gambit could tempt Beijing with a favorable risk/reward balance…Full Report

Frequently asked questions

Could China take over TSMC without invading Taiwan?

Collins and Erickson argue it is a plausible risk. In their hypothetical scenario, months of PLA live-fire exercises, inspection demands and shipping disruption weaken Taiwan’s economy and politics until Chinese state-backed buyers offer to purchase a 51% controlling stake in TSMC, pledging to defend air and sea traffic once the deal closes.

What is the Silicon Hegemon report?

Silicon Hegemon is a 2023 report by Gabriel Collins and Andrew S. Erickson for Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy, report no. 09.27.23. The report asks whether China could take over Taiwan’s semiconductor industry without invading, using a detailed hypothetical scenario set in 2027 to illustrate how economic coercion might succeed.

How much could TSMC’s value fall under Chinese military pressure?

In the report’s hypothetical scenario, TSMC’s market capitalization falls from $700 billion at the onset of China’s action to $300 billion. That collapse in value makes a buyout cheaper and sets up an offer from Chinese state-linked investors, backed by a China Investment Corporation credit line, to buy a controlling stake.

Why is the Taiwan semiconductor scenario set in 2027?

The scenario opens on August 1, 2027, after China’s armed forces have met Xi Jinping’s Centennial Military Building Goal. By then, the authors posit, the military offers Xi a full toolbox of capabilities regarding Taiwan, and years of intensifying pressure have opened new vulnerabilities in Taiwan’s economy to PRC ownership and influence.

How could China disrupt Taiwan’s trade without a formal blockade?

The scenario relies on declared exercises rather than a declared blockade. Beijing warns mariners and airmen away, requires aircraft to land first at Xiamen or Quanzhou and ships to submit to inspection, and PRC escorts turn others away. London-based insurers’ warnings deter shippers, and most air cargo services halt operations.

Leave a Reply

Trending