Perspective matters. The roughly $15 billion worth of military assistance and equipment the U.S. has provided to Ukraine through Presidential drawdowns of existing Defense Department stocks (PDA) and Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative (USAI) sounds like a lot. In raw absolute terms, it is. But it pales in comparison to what the U.S. spent in Iraq and Afghanistan. The tiny little chart you see outlined in red on the right side of the chart above this paragraph is the aid to Ukraine scaled to actual size versus the massive amounts we spent in CENTCOM.

The difference in returns on each security investment is stark. Despite more than $1 trillion in cumulative U.S. spend over two decades, an Afghan government facing gunmen in pickups crumpled in weeks. In contrast, a Ukrainian state receiving a tiny fraction as much has held its own against a full-scale onslaught by one of the larger nation-state militaries on the planet.

We would need to more than double what we’ve provided Ukraine thus far in 2022 just to match the inflation-adjusted amount DoD spent in Fiscal 2021 on Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria. Let’s stay the course knowing that each dollar of equipment and assistance provided to Ukraine now saves lives there and bolsters our security here as well. Isolationism will not bring peace but investment in Ukraine’s defense helps hold the line against the forces of division and disorder that Russia and its ilk represent.

Frequently asked questions

How much military aid has the U.S. given Ukraine?

As of late September 2022, the U.S. had provided roughly $15 billion in military assistance and equipment to Ukraine. The aid flowed through Presidential drawdowns of existing Defense Department stocks (PDA) and the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative (USAI). Gabriel Collins notes the sum is large in absolute terms but small relative to past U.S. war spending.

How does U.S. aid to Ukraine compare with spending in Afghanistan and Iraq?

U.S. aid to Ukraine is a tiny fraction of what the U.S. spent in the CENTCOM region. The U.S. spent more than $1 trillion over two decades in Afghanistan, and 2022 aid to Ukraine would need to more than double to match inflation-adjusted DoD spending on Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria in Fiscal 2021.

What are PDA and USAI in U.S. aid to Ukraine?

PDA and USAI are the two channels the article identifies for U.S. military aid to Ukraine. PDA refers to Presidential drawdowns of existing Defense Department stocks, while USAI is the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative. Together they accounted for the roughly $15 billion in assistance and equipment the U.S. had provided by late September 2022.

Is military aid to Ukraine a good return on investment?

Gabriel Collins argues that aid to Ukraine has delivered far better returns than U.S. spending in Afghanistan. More than $1 trillion over two decades could not keep Afghanistan’s government from crumpling in weeks, while Ukraine, receiving a tiny fraction as much, has held its own against a full-scale onslaught by a large nation-state military.

2 responses to “U.S. Military Assistance to Ukraine in Perspective”

  1. […] U.S. military assistance to Ukraine in perspective […]

Leave a Reply

Trending